When a relative of yours announces that theyre having a child, its usually cause for celebration.

However, theres a time and a place for this sort of happy moment.

Generally, you want to make the announcement its own thing instead of having it overlap with other celebrations.

Article image

Redditor u/OkSeaworthiness6960 went viral on the AITAH online group aftersharinga disagreement he had with his family over the holidays.

According to the author, instead of a proper Christmas present, his sister gave him a wrapped-uppregnancytest.

However, he called her out on this, claiming that this doesnt count as a proper Xmas gift.

Man in red shirt wrapping gifts near Christmas tree.

He asked for the internets verdict.

Itd be weird to go back on your promise.

Of course, you could argue that the mother-to-bes new top priority is her child.

Text about a family discussion on whether a pregnancy announcement qualifies as a Christmas present.

As per Investopedia, itcostsa lot of money to raise a child in the United States.

Of course, the exact expenses will vary depending on your lifestyle and where you live.

The cost was $56,190 for private colleges.

Text discussing family gift practices and age of youngest sibling at 24.

These numbers include tuition, fees, and room and board.

Thats not great for you if you hope to ask them to babysit your kid in the future.

If your children are your top priority in life, thats all fair.

Text excerpt about a sister giving a pregnancy test as a Christmas gift and the brother’s confusion.

That being said, they cant be your only priority.

People are more than just parents.

And life is more than just about raising kids.

Woman holding a pregnancy test with a smile, touching her belly, announcing pregnancy.

There has to be some sort of balance.

Youve got other important people in your life to maintain relationships with, namely your family and friends.

If you constantly neglect and ignore them, you might regret it later.

Text discussing a sister’s pregnancy announcement during a Secret Santa exchange, causing mixed feelings.

Meanwhile, you also cant forget your career, passion projects, creative hobbies, health, etc.

Meanwhile, theres the question of timing.

Broadly speaking, you shouldnt make any important announcements if they overlap with massive events or other peoples celebrations.

Text discussing a pregnancy announcement not being considered a Christmas present.

This is so that the event doesnt suddenly start revolving around you and you alone.

For instance, you shouldnt announce that youre pregnant or engaged at someone elses wedding or engagement party.

Similarly, it feels a bit bizarre to announce your pregnancy via a Secret Santa gift.

Woman holding a positive pregnancy test by a window, capturing a moment of anticipation and emotion.

Such an important piece of news deserves the right setting.

You could use it as a way to finish the family gathering on a high note.

And it doesnt have to be anything overly elaborate.

Christmas presents with colorful bows surrounded by festive decorations.

Its also helpful if your partner is there by your side to offer you their support.

Image credits:alexlucru123 (not the actual photo)

Most readers were on the guys side.

Heres what they said after reading through what happened

Not everyone was convinced.

Reddit thread discussing a brother’s reaction to his sister’s pregnancy announcement as a Christmas gift.

Some people called the man out for how he reacted

Thanks!

Check out the results:

Reddit comment on pregnancy announcement not being a suitable Christmas gift.

Text response about pregnancy announcement not counting as a Christmas present.

Reddit comment humorously discussing a pregnancy announcement not counting as a handmade Christmas gift.

Comment joking about a pregnancy announcement not being a Christmas present.

Comment discussing a sister’s pregnancy announcement not being a Christmas present.

Reddit comment criticizing a pregnancy announcement as a Christmas present idea.

Reddit comment suggesting a negative COVID test as a birthday gift, related to pregnancy announcement not counting as a present.

Comment discussing why a pregnancy announcement shouldn’t replace a Christmas present.

Text response to sister upset about pregnancy announcement as Xmas present.

Comment on sibling disagreement over pregnancy announcement as a Christmas gift.

Reddit comment about pregnancy announcement and Christmas gift exchange.

Reddit comment discussing pregnancy announcement as a Christmas gift.

Comment discussing pregnancy announcement as Christmas gift.

Text exchange about sibling’s pregnancy announcement and Christmas gift expectations.

Reddit comment about pregnancy announcement not being a valid Xmas present, addressing a sister’s reaction.

Comment discussing a sister’s pregnancy announcement not being a suitable Christmas present.

Comment criticizing pregnancy announcement as a Christmas present.

Comment discussing parental favoritism in a family-related story.

Reddit comment discussing pregnancy announcement as a Christmas gift.

Comment discussing pregnancy announcement as a Christmas present.

Comment discussing noise-making gifts for a child until their teen years, then switching to a glitter glue gun.

Text comment about pregnancy announcement not being a Christmas gift from user k2miners.

Reddit comment about pregnancy announcement not being a proper Christmas gift.

Comment on pregnancy announcement as a Christmas gift, suggesting a more thoughtful Secret Santa present.

Reddit comment criticizing reaction to sister’s pregnancy announcement as a Christmas present.

Comment criticizing reaction to sister’s pregnancy announcement as a Christmas present.

Comment about a sister’s pregnancy announcement not being an adequate Christmas gift, sparking an emotional response.