Share

Certain people in our lives are just trickier to buygiftsfor than others.

Some folks in relationships find this to be particularly true with theirin-laws.

But not forthis guy.

Article image

He thought that he picked out the perfect funny present for the woman who raised his spouse.

However, it completely backfired, sending his mother-in-law to the hospital.

But is it a stereotype if science proves it to be true?

Elderly woman with glasses and white hair in a bun, wearing a mustard turtleneck and brown blazer, looking concerned.

Think about what she enjoys.

Does she love gardening, traveling, or reading?

A good gift also depends on the relationship.

Text discussing MIL demanding man pay hospital bill after breaking his gift, a political mug.

If youre close, something more personal can be meaningful.

And sometimes, a physical gift isnt even necessary.

But if you do give something, presentation matters.

Hands holding mugs, one with “Fell For It Again Award” text, highlighting a humorous gift concept.

A beautifully wrapped gift can turn even the simplest present into something special, Hartung said.

Most in-laws do not expect a separate gift from their kids spouse, additionally notes OBrien.

If she loves to have fun and joke around, then including a gag gift is ok.

Text about MIL birthday gift mug incident, highlighting a humorous response before a dinner outing.

It depends on the relationship and her sense of humor.

But it should never be something that could be misinterpreted or feel like its at her expense.

If theres any doubt, its always better to go with something thoughtful.

Text about MIL’s reaction to a gift during a family dinner.

Some gifts, though well-intended, can feel impersonal or even a little off the mark, said Hartung.

Avoid anything too practicallike household cleaning supplies, vacuums, or workout gearunless shes specifically asked for them.

Even things like workout classes, diet-related products, or anti-aging products and treatments can send the wrong message.

Man stressed, hand on forehead, after MIL demands payment for her hospital bill due to gift incident.

If youre unsure what to give, something simple but thoughtful can go a long way.

Check out the results:

MIL angrily smashes gift mug, injures ankle, demands hospital bill payment.

Text from a story about a MIL demanding payment for a hospital bill due to breaking a gift.

“AITA For Refusing To Pay For My MIL’s Deductible After She Smashed The Gift I Gave Her?”

“AITA For Refusing To Pay For My MIL’s Deductible After She Smashed The Gift I Gave Her?”

Reddit comment criticizing a man for paying hospital bills after MIL injures herself smashing his gift.

Comment suggesting giving Monopoly money instead of paying hospital bill after MIL’s injury.

Reddit comment criticizing MIL’s demand for payment after gift incident, warning of future “tantrums.

Reddit comment discussing MIL, husband, and wife dynamics after a family conflict.

Reddit comment discussing MIL injury, emphasizing consequences of self-inflicted actions.

Comment about MIL demanding payment for a hospital bill after injuring herself breaking a gift.

Reddit comment questioning MIL’s behavior and assigning no blame to man for her injury.

Reddit comment discussing MIL’s tantrum over a gift, suggesting she’s responsible for her actions.

Comment discussing MIL hospital bill after breaking a gift.

Reddit comment criticizing MIL for poor behavior after smashing a gift and demanding medical bill payment.

Comment on Reddit discussing MIL demanding payment for hospital bill after smashing a gift.

Reddit comment discussing a situation involving MIL, a hospital bill, and a smashed gift.

Comment discussing MIL’s demand for a hospital bill payment after injuring herself breaking a gift.

Reddit comment discussing MIL, gift incident, and differing views.

Comment discussing responsibility for hospital bill after gift incident.

Comment criticizing a man for giving an unwanted gift, suggesting he should pay a hospital bill.

Reddit comment criticizing gift choice, causing MIL upset and demanding hospital bill payment.

Comment discussing triggered reactions, mentioning “snowflakes” and justifying YTA label.

Comment discussing MIL injury after breaking a gift and demanding hospital bill payment.

Text screenshot discussing a family incident involving a banner and a damaged relationship, referencing a mug.

Comment criticizing a man for a gift-related incident causing his MIL’s injury and hospital bill issue.

Comment on Reddit discussing responsibility in a situation involving a mother-in-law’s hospital bill after an incident.

Comment discussing an argument about a gift and accidental injury, with the term “TA” used.

Reddit comment discussing consequences of giving a controversial gift, questioning motives and respect.

Comment discussing mother-in-law feeling embarrassed and demanding payment for hospital bill after gift incident.

Comment discussing MIL demand for hospital bill payment after a gift incident.